I think things need to get going on this so I have made this topic with seemingly the 3 most popular proposals. All 3 have their differences, please vote for your favourite. When you have voted please post the name of the persons proposal you prefer and a short sentence explaining why. For example:
<name>
-short explanation
This will make it clearer to everyone
The one with most votes can then be submitted to Don as our FINAL proposal and maybe she can get things moving. Hopefully we can nip this thing in the bud and get this quickmatch renovation well under way.
Votes so far:
Aly's (t3h j3w) proposal: 11 votes
Tony's (iAmaLeGeNd) proposal: 3 votes
TimmyJohn's proposal: 0 votes
Aly's (t3h j3w) proposal:
http://xwis.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=153899
Ok, first of all, I think it's important to name the current QM maps of which the ones where Yuri can be faced are marked. I admittably don't have much experience playing vs Yuri so I'll depend on you guys to tell me which maps you want to play yuri on. I've added a lot of the maps prep suggested, just not as many.
So what's different about my plan? I retain the old maps. That's important I think. Just taking out the ones which are obiously imbalanced (anytown). I think we already got a pretty good list. I know they're players who want to add some spice so I've added more maps, but I'm not adding a ridiculous amount of maps. I also tried to add some maps which favour allied and some which favour sov. And finally, adding some maps to the Yuri vs Sov/allied matchup.
A=Allied
S=Sov
Y=Yuri
Current YR QM Maps:
1) GSF <
2)Dry Heat <
3)Offense Defense<
4) Death Valley
5)Heartland<
6)Anytown America
7)Hidden Valley<
8)South Pacific
9)The Alamo
10)Defcon 6
11)Dune Patrol<
12)Hammer and Sickle
13)Isle
14)Montana<
15)Urban<
16)CS<
17)Dustbowl<
18)Face Down
19)Lake Blitzen
20) No wimps
21)Tour of Egypt
22)BF<
23)Meat Grinder
24)New Heights
25)Official Tournament Map A
26)Tanyas
27)Deadman's Ridge
28)Official map b
29)Paris Revisited<
30)Roundhouse Kick
31)Sahara Mirage<
32)Sovereign Land
33)Stormy Weather
34)A hill between
35)Cold War
36)Depth Charge
37)Pinch Point
Super Weapon Settings:
SvS, SvA, AvA, YvY = Random, unless listed below.
YvA = Off.
YvS = On.
The following matchups I believe require SW always on. Let me know.
Isle of War (SvA,SvS), Mayday (SvA), Death Valley (SvS, AvA, SvA), Hammer and Sickle (SvS, AvS), Deadman's Ridge (SvS, SvA), Depth Charge (AvS)
Maps to be be removed from battles which don't involve yuri (svs,ava,avs):
-Anytown Amerika
Maps to be eliminated from Yuri battles (yvy,yvs,yva):
-Urban rush
-Dune Patrol: YvA
-BF: YvA
Maps to be added to battles which don't involve Yuri (svs,ava,avs) :
-Heck Freezes Over
-El Dorado
-Malibu Cliffs
-Four Corners
-Hail Mary
-Valley of Gems
-Bridging the Gap
-Path beyond 2
-Twin Peaks
-Brink of Disaster
-Loaded Barrel
Maps to be added to Yuri battles (yvy,yvs,yva):
Copying from Prep's list..
-Oceanside AvY
-Head for the hills
-Tanyas Training Grounds < Dunno bout that one.
-Heck Freezes Over <again
-Snowball's Chance
-Arena 33 forever
-East vs Best AvY <might be good
-Double Trouble AvY
-Tower of Power
-Defcon 6
-Malibu Cliffs
-Mt Olympus
-Brink of Disaster AvY
Tony's (iAmaLeGeNd) proposal:
http://xwis.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=153650
With a lot of help from timmyjohn, ANOTHEr, and justin and the rest of the community(idk all ur names lol)
This is my final proposal.
Ok assuming all maps from Qm were wiped out and htis is from Scratch.
also assuming all maps Are mirror matched unless stated other wise (ava , svs , yvy)
Game settings
Avy-Random Super weapons
Svy-supers always on
Avs-Random supers
mirror matches-Random supers
MY Map List (remember some things can be fixed later on)
isle of war-Avs
Blood feud- Avs
Dune patrol- Avs
Dustbowl - avs avy
HAil mary- Avs (i honestly think yuri would rape this map)
HIdden valley-AvS
a hill between-Only mirrors
let tehre be fight-avs
Loaded barrel-all
Meatgrinder-Avs
Sahara mirage-All
Sovereign land-All
Twin peaks-Avs
Urban rush-Mirrors only
Brink of disaster-all
CArvilles convoy-all
City under seige-Avs
Country swing-all
Dry heat-all
Facedown-Avs
Golden state freeway-All
Head for the hills-all
Heartland-all
Isle of oades-Avs
Lost lake-all
Montana DMZ-all
Mount olympus-all
Oceanside-all
Pacific heights-AVs
Paris revisited-Avs
Rockets red glare-Avs
Roundhouse kick-Avs
SHrapnel mountain-Avs
Sinkhole-Avy Svy
Snowvalley-Avs
Snowballs chance - Avs
South pacific-Avs
Tsunami- avs
Valley of gems Avs
Bering strait-avs
Bidging the gap-all
Defcon 6 -mirrors
MAlibu cliffs-ALL
SIberian wastes-ALL
Heck freezes over-ALL
Off tourny a - AVS
Off tourny b-AVS
DOuble trouble-Avy
Offense defense-Avy avs
Tour of egypt-Avs
Austin Tx-Mirrors
Death valley girl- AVY
SEa of isolation-Avy,
Stormy weather-AVS
Army of the potomac-AVs, avy, Svy ( navy cant be built here so no worries on boomer rushes.)
Thats the map list i would like to see in YR QM
and the matchups, sure its not 100% perfect but nothing is,
i know for fact its 100% better then what qm is now tho.
TimmyJohn's proposal:
http://xwis.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=153695
This is my full proposal, it includes current yr/ra2 qm maps + more...
Sov vs Sov random s.w
Yuri vs Sov supers on
Allied vs Sov random s.w
Allied vs Allied random s.w
Allied vs Yuri supers on s.w
Yuri vs Yuri random s.w
Yuri = Y
Allied = A
Soviets = S
The Alamo (SvS SvA AvA)
Blood Fued (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Deadman's Ridge (SvS AvA SvA YvY)
Death Valley Girl (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Dune Patrol (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Hidden Valley (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
A Hill Between (SvS SvA YvY)
Isle Of War (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
May Day - (YvY)
Meat Grinder (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
New Heights (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Urban Rush (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Anytown America (YvY)
Country Swing (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Dry Heat (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Facedown (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Golden State Fwy (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Heartland (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Lake Blitzen (SvS AvA YvY)
Pinch Point (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Sahara Mirage (Mirror Match)
Sovereign Land (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Montana DMZ (ANY FACTION VS ANY FACTION)
Paris Revisited (ANY FACTION VS ANY FACTION)
Snow Valley (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Offense Defense (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
South Pacific (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Tanya's Training Grounds (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Tour Of Egypt (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Official Tournament A (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Official Tournament B (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Hail Mary (Mirror Match)
Let There Be A Fight (SvS SvA YvY AvA)
Little Piece Of Dune (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Loaded Barrel (Mirror Match)
Twin Peaks (Mirror Match)
Snowball's Chance (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Isle of Oades (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Rush Hour (SvY AvY)
Depth Charge (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Malibu Cliffs (ANY FACTION Vs ANY FACTION)
Little Big Lake (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
City Under Siege (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
DC Uprising (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Hammer And Sickle (SvS SvA AvA YvY)
Stormy Weather (Mirror Match)
Army Of The Potomac - (SvS AvA SvA)
Siberian Wastes (SvY AvY YvY)
Tsunami (Mirror Match)
Area 33 Forever ( SvY YvY YvA)
Defcon 6 (SvS SvA AvA)
Edited by Keano, 11 May 2009 - 02:59 PM.
